I'm aware that Super GRUB2 Disk's author tried to handle that, I'll ask him for comments. @DocAciD I don't have a Lenovo, ThinkPad or a ThinkCentre, Getting the same on TinyCoreLiInux (CorePlus), URL; http://tinycorelinux.net/downloads.html, The ISO must be UEFI-bootable and have a UEFI64 boot file \EFI\BOOT\BOOTX64.EFI Ventoy is a tool to create bootable USB drive for ISO/WIM/IMG/VHD (x)/EFI files. Format XFS in Linux: sudo mkfs -t xfs /dev/sdb1, It may be related to the motherboard USB 2.0/3.0 port. If so, please include aflag to stop this check from happening! However, I'm not sure whether chainloading of shims are allowed, and how it would work if you try to load for example Ubuntu when you already have Fedora's shim loaded. New version of Rescuezilla (2.4) not working properly. BUT with Ventoy 1.0.74 legacy boot from the same ISO I get a black square in centre of menu (USB LED is flashing so appears to load). EndeavourOS_Atlantis_neo-21_5.iso boots OK using UEFI64 on Ventoy and grubfm. But, just like GRUB, I assert that this matter needs to be treated as a bug that warrants fixing, which is the reason I created this issue in the first place. privacy statement. I you want to spare yourself some setup headaches, take a USB crafted as a Ventoy or SG2D USB that contains KL ISO files, directly. And of course, by the same logic, anything unsigned should not boot when Secure Boot is active. due to UEFI setup password in a corporate laptop which the user don't know. A lot of work to do. unsigned kernel still can not be booted. Currently, on x64 systems, Ventoy is able to run when Secure Boot is enabled, through the use of MokManager to enroll the certificate with which Ventoy's EFI executable is signed. Download Debian net installer. Preventing malicious programs is not the task of secure boot. These WinPE have different user scripts inside the ISO files. My guesd is it does not. I have installed Ventoy on my USB and I have added some ISO's files : It should be specially noted that, no matter USB drive or local disk, all the data will be lost after install Ventoy, please be very careful. Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community. Now, if Microsoft finally relinquished their abusive policy about not accepting GPLv3 code for Secure Boot signing and Ventoy was updated not to allow unsigned bootloaders when Secure Boot is enabled (i.e. @MFlisar Hiren's Boot CD was down with UEFI (legacy still has some problem), manjaro-kde-20.0-rc3-200422-linux56.iso BOOT I used Rufus on a new USB with the same iso image, and when I booted to it with UEFI it booted successfully. openSUSE-Tumbleweed-XFCE-Live-x86_64-Snapshot20200402-Media - 925 MB, star-kirk-2.1.0-xfce-amd64-live.iso - 518 MB, Porteus-CINNAMON-v5.0rc1-x86_64.iso - 300 MB I have the same error with EndeavorOS_Atlantis_neo_21_5.iso using ventoy 1.0.70. the EndeavorOS iso boots with no issues when on it's on usb, but not through ventoy. 2. chromeos_14816.99.0_reven_recovery_stable-channel_mp-v2.bin fails to boot on BIOS & UEFI. Copy the efisys.bin from C: > Windows > Boot > DVD > EFI > en-US to your desktop 3. You can press left or right arrow keys to scroll the menu. @chromer030 hello. But, even as I don't actually support the idea that Secure Boot is useless if someone has physical access to the device (that was mostly Steve positing this as a means to justify that not being able to detect Secure Boot breaches on USB media isn't that big a deal), I do believe there currently still exist a bit too many ways to ensure that you can compromise a machine, if you have access to said machine. On one of my Laptop Problem with HBCD_PE_x64.iso Uefi on start from Desktop error with Autoit v3: Pintool.exe Application error. Ventoy How did you get it to be listed by Ventoy? There are many kinds of WinPE. Sign in 7. EFI Blocked !!!!!!! Sign in That would be my preference, because someone who wants to bypass Secure Boot indiscriminately, without disabling Secure Boot altogether, should have a clue what they are doing, and the problem with presenting options as a dialog is that you end up with tutorials that advise users to pick the less secure option, because whoever wrote happened to find the other choices inconvenient without giving much thought about the end result. Which is why you want to have as many of these enabled in parallel when they exist (such as TPM + Secure Boot, i.e. can u test ? I've been trying to do something I've done a milliion times before: This has always worked for me. There are many kinds of WinPE. Hiren's Boot CD with UEFI support? - Super User For Hiren's BootCD HBCD_PE_x64.iso has been tested in UEFI mode. Do I need a custom shim protocol? Have a question about this project? Hi FadeMind, the woraround for that Problem with WinPE10_8_Sergei_Strelec_x86_x64_2019.12.28_English.iso is that you must copy the SSTR to the root of yout USB drive than all apps are avalaible. How to Fix No bootfile found for UEFI on a Laptop or Desktop PC - YouTube Shim itself is signed with Microsoft key. Therefore, Ventoy/Grub should be altered as follows: Hopefully this shouldn't be too complex to add, though it may require some research, and modifying GRUB to do just that might require a lot of work. Any suggestions, bugs? Time-saving software and hardware expertise that helps 200M users yearly. Ventoy 1.0.55: bypass Windows 11 requirements check during installation How to Download Windows 11 ISO and Perform a Clean Install | Beebom All the .efi files may not be booted. Although it could be disabled on all typical motherboards in UEFI setup menu, sometimes it's not easily possible e.g. @adrian15, could you tell us your progress on this? I'd be interested in a shim for Rufus as well, since I have the same issue with wanting UEFI:NTFS signed for Secure Boot, but using GRUB 2 code for the driver, that makes Secure Boot signing it impossible. If you did the above as described, exactly, then you now have a good Ventoy install of latest version, but /dev/sdX1 will be type exFAT and we want to change that to ext4, so start gparted, find that partition (make sure it is unmounted via right click in gparted), format it to ext4 and make sure to . Fedora-Workstation-Live-x86_64-32-1.6.iso: Works fine, all hard drive can be properly detected. Well occasionally send you account related emails. Maybe the image does not support X64 UEFI" Shims and other Secure Boot signed chain loaders do not remove the feature of warning about boot loaders that have not been signed (by either MS or the Shim holders). - . Windows 10 32bit This iso seems to have some problem with UEFI. V4 is legacy version. 1.0.84 UEFI www.ventoy.net ===> You can open the ISO in 7zip and look for yourself. A least, I'd expect that a tutorial that advises a user to modify a JSON file to have done a bit more research into the topic and provide better advice. On the other hand, the expectation is that most users would only get the warning very occasionally, and you definitely want to bring to their attention that they might want to be careful about the current bootloader they are trying to boot, in case they haven't paid that much attention to where they got their image @ventoy, @pbatard, any comments on my solution? 1. I've hacked-up PreLoader once again and managed to cleanly chainload Ubuntu ISO with Secure Boot enabled. These WinPE have different user scripts inside the ISO files. Official FAQ I have checked the official FAQ. but CorePure64-13.1.iso does not as it does not contain any EFI boot files. So that means that Ventoy will need to use a different key indeed. (I updated to the latest version of Ventoy). to your account. No bootfile found for UEFI with Ventoy, But OK witth rufus. Help The point of this issue is that people are under the impression that because Ventoy supports Secure Boot, they will get the same level of "security" booting Secure Boot compliant media through Ventoy as if they had booted that same media directly, which is indeed a fair expectation to have, since the whole point of boot media creation software is to have the converted media behave as close as possible as the original would. In WIMBOOT mode (ctrl+w) I get 'Loading files. xx%' and then screen resolution changes and get nice Windows Setup GUI. Would MS sign boot code which can change memory/inject user files, write sectors, etc.? It woks only with fallback graphic mode. eficompress infile outfile. I'm afraid I'm very busy with other projects, so I haven't had a chance. Else I would have disabled Secure Boot altogether, since the end result it the same. Last time I tried that usb flash was nearly full, maybe thats why I couldnt do it. Try updating it and see if that fixes the issue. Format UDF in Windows: format x: /fs:udf /q [issue]: ventoy can't boot any iso on Dell Inspiron 3558, but can boot "No bootfile found for UEFI! sol-11_3-live-x86.iso | 1.22 GB, gnewsense-live-4.0-amd64-gnome.iso | 1.10 GB, hyperbola-milky-way-v0.3.1-dual.iso | 680 MB, kibojoe-17.09final-stable-x86_64-code21217.iso | 950 MB, uruk-gnu-linux-3.0-2020-6-alpha-1.iso | 1.35 GB, Redcore.Linux.Hardened.2004.KDE.amd64.iso | 3.5 GB, Drauger_OS-7.5.1-beta2-AMD64.iso | 1.8 GB, MagpieOS-Gnome-2.4-Eva-2018.10.01-x86_64.iso | 2.3 GB, kaisenlinuxrolling1.0-amd64.iso | 2.80 GB, chakra-2019.09.26-a022cb57-x86_64.iso | 2.7 GB, Regata_OS_19.1_en-US.x86_64-19.1.50.iso | 2.4 GB. Win10_21H2_BrazilianPortuguese_x64.iso also boots fine in Legacy mode on IdeaPad 300 with Ventoy 1.0.57. unsigned .efi file still can not be chainloaded. Can you add the exactly iso file size and test environment information? @steve6375 When it asks Delete the key (s), select Yes. They can choose to run a signed Ubuntu EFI file and Ventoy can change it's default function using scripts and file injection. So all Ventoy's behavior doesn't change the secure boot policy. How to Perform a Clean Install of Windows 11. Discovery and usage of shim protocol of loaded shim binary for global UEFI validation functions (validation policy override with shim verification), Shim protocol unregistration of loaded shim binary (to prevent confusion among shims of multiple vendors and registration of multiple protocols which are handled by different chainloaded shims). Optional custom shim protocol registration (not included in this build, creates issues). Ventoy does support Windows 10 and 11 and users can bypass the Windows 11 hardware check when installing. So it is pointless for Ventoy to only boot Secure EFI files once the user has 'whitelisted' it. Then congratulations: You have completely removed any benefits of using Secure Boot for any person who enrolled Ventoy on their Secure Boot computer. If Secure Boot is enabled, signature validation of any chain loaded, If the signature validation fails (i.e. 4 Ways to Fix Ventoy if It's Not Working [Booting Issues] The fact that it's also able to check if a signed USB installer wasn't tampered with is just a nice bonus. Getting the same error with Arch Linux. I'll test it on a real hardware a bit later. If the ISO is on the tested list, then clearly it is a problem with your particular equipment, so you need to give the details. For instance, if you produce digitally signed software for Windows, to ensure that your users can validate that when they run an application, they can tell with certainty whether it comes from you or not, you really don't want someone to install software on the user computer that will suddenly make applications that weren't signed by you look as if they were signed by you. All the userspace applications don't need to be signed. Win10UEFI Try updating it and see if that fixes the issue. The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: Please test this ISO file with VirtualMachine(e.g. . Ventoy supports ISO, WIM, IMG, VHD(x), EFI files using an exFAT filesystem. espero les sirva, pueden usar rufus, ventoy, easy to boot, etc. da1: quirks=0x2. I assume that file-roller is not preserving boot parameters, use another iso creation tool. So any method that allows users to boot their media without having to explicitly disable Secure Boot can be seen as a nice thing to have even if it comes at the price of reducing the overall security of one's computer. But i have added ISO file by Rufus. Will there be any? It is pointless to try to enforce Secure Boot from a USB drive. With this option, in theory, Ventoy can boot fine no matter whether the secure boot in the BIOS is enabled or disabled. It gets to the root@archiso ~ # prompt just fine using first boot option. Maybe I can get Ventoy's grub signed with MS key. 10 comments andycuong commented on Mar 17, 2021 completed meeuw mentioned this issue on Jul 31, 2021 [issue]: Can't boot Ventoy UEFI Native (Without CSM) on HP ProBook 640g1 #1031 For example, Ventoy can be modified to somehow chainload full chain of distros shim grub kernel, or custom validation functions could be made, which would, for example, validate and accept files signed with certificates in DB + a set of custom certificates (like ones embedded in distros' Shims), or even validate and automatically extract Shims embedded certificates and override EFI validation functions (as it's done currently to completely disable validation), but is this kind of complexity worth it for a USB boot utility which is implemented to be simple and convenient? But . https://abf.openmandriva.org/product_build_lists. Now, that one can currently break the trust chain somewhere down the line, by inserting a malicious program at the first level where the trust stops being validated, which, incidentally, as a method (since I am NOT calling Ventoy malicious here) is very similar to what Ventoy is doing for Windows boot, is irrelevant to the matter, because one can very much conceive an OS that is being secured all the way (and, once again, if Microsoft were to start doing just that, then that would most likely mark the end of being able to use Ventoy with Windows ISOs since it would no longer be able to inject an executable that isn't signed by Microsoft as part of the boot process) and that validates the signature of every single binary it runs along the way which means that the trust chain needs to start somewhere and (as far as user providable binaries are concerned) that trust chain starts with Secure Boot. So, Fedora has shim that loads only Fedoras files. For these who select to bypass secure boot. Ventoy also supports BIOS Legacy. i was test in VMWare 16 for rufus, winsetupusb, yumiits okay, https://drive.google.com/file/d/1_mYChRFanLEdyttDvT-cn6zH0o6KX7Th/view?usp=sharing. I am getting the same error, and I confirmed that the iso has UEFI support. Have a question about this project? So, this is debatable. Which means that, if you have a TPM chip, then it certainly makes little sense to want to use its features with Secure Boot disabled. Thus, on a system where Secure Boot is enabled, users should rightfully expect to be alerted if the EFI bootloader of an ISO booted through Ventoy is not Secure Boot signed or if its signature doesn't validate. if this issue was addressed), it could probably be Secure Boot signed, in the same manner as UEFI:NTFS was itself Secure Boot signed. Well occasionally send you account related emails. However, I guess it should be possible to automatically enroll ALL needed keys to shim from grub module on the first boot (when the user enrolls my ENROLL_THIS_CERT_INTO_MOKMANAGER.crt) and handle unsigned efi binaries as a special case or just require to sign them with user-generated key? my pleasure and gladly happen :) That error i have also with WinPE 10 Sergei is booting with that error ( on Skylake Processor). Finally, click on "64-bit Download" and it will start downloading Windows 11 from Microsoft's server. ventoy.json should be placed at the 1st partition which has the larger capacity (The partition to store ISO files). I remember that @adrian15 tried to create a sets of fully trusted chainload chains ***> wrote: If a user is booting a lot of unsigned bootloaders with Secure Boot enabled, they clearly should disable Secure Boot in their settings, because, for what they are doing, it is pretty much pointless. How to suppress iso files under specific directory . Worked fine for me on my Thinkpad T420. Without complex workarounds, XP does not support being installed from USB. 1.- comprobar que la imagen que tienes sea de 64 bits In this situation, with current Ventoy architecture, nothing will boot (even Fedora ISO), because the validation (and loading) files signed with Shim certificate requires support from the bootloader and every chainloaded .efi file (it uses custom protocol, regular EFI functions can't be used. Some questions about using KLV-Airedale - Page 4 - Puppy Linux () no boot file found for uefi. I made a VHD of an arch installation and installed the vtoyboot mod and it keeps on giving me the no UEFI error. 1All the steps bellow only need to be done once for each computer when booting Ventoy at the first time. see http://tinycorelinux.net/13.x/x86_64/release/ That's not at all how I see it (and from what I read above also not @ventoy sees it). These WinPE have different user scripts inside the ISO files. Option2: Use Ventoy's grub which is signed with MS key. Acronis True Image 2020 24.6.1 Build 25700 in Legacy is working in Memdisk mode on 1.0.08 beta 2 but on another older Version of Acronis 2020 sometimes is boot's up but the most of the time he's crashing after loading acronis loader text. Perform a scan to check if there are any existing errors on the USB. Ventoy About File Checksum 1. Main Edition Support. So the new ISO file can be booted fine in a secure boot enviroment. By the way, this issue could be closed, couldn't it? Remain what in the install program Ventoy2Disk.exe . Now, if Microsoft finally relinquished their abusive policy about not accepting GPLv3 code for Secure Boot signing and Ventoy was updated not to allow unsigned bootloaders when Secure Boot is enabled (i.e. 3. Tested ISO: https://github.com/rescuezilla/rescuezilla/releases/download/2.4/rescuezilla-2.4-64bit.jammy.iso. mishab_mizzunet 1 yr. ago So from ventoy 1.0.09, an option for secure boot is added in Ventoy2Disk.exe/Ventoy2Disk.sh and default is disabled. This software will repair common computer errors, protect you from file loss, malware, hardware failure and optimize your PC for maximum performance. Can't install Windows 7 ISO, no install media found ? If you have a faulty USB stick, then youre likely to encounter booting issues. This file is not signed by Microsoft for 'Secure Boot' - do you still wish to boot from it? You can install Ventoy to USB drive, Removable HD, SD Card, SATA HDD, SSD, NVMe . The Ultimate Linux USB : r/linuxmasterrace - reddit Now Rufus has achieved support for secure boot as now NTFS:UEFI Driver is signed for secure boot by Microsoft. Already on GitHub? P.S. https://nyancat.fandom.com/wiki/MEMZ_Nyan_Cat to your account, Hi ! it doesn't support Bluetooth and doesn't have nvidia's proprietary drivers but it's very easy to install. If you want you can toggle Show all devices option, then all the devices will be in the list. I rarely get any problems with other menu systems based on grub2\grub4dos\syslinux\isolinux, just Ventoy gives problems. I think it's OK. However, users have reported issues with Ventoy not working properly and encountering booting issues. Ventoy supports both BIOS Legacy and UEFI, however, some ISO files do not support UEFI mode. same here on ThinkPad x13 as for @rderooy It means that the secure boot solution doesn't work with your machine, so you need to turn off the option, and disable secure boot in the BIOS. Besides, I'm considering that: If someone has physical access to a system and that system is enabled to boot from a USB drive, then all they need to do is boot to an OS such as Ubuntu or WindowsPE or WindowsToGo from that USB drive (these OS's are all signed and so will Secure boot). You signed in with another tab or window. I think it's ok as long as they don't break the secure boot policy. So, Secure Boot is not required for TPM-based encryption to work correctly. Maybe the image does not support X64 UEFI! all give ERROR on HP Laptop : Yes, I already understood my mistake. But, whereas this is good security practice, that is not a requirement. It's what Secure Boot is designed to do on account of being a trust chain mechanism that, when enabled, MUST alert if trust is broken. Cantt load some ISOs - Ventoy plzz help. The user should be notified when booting an unsigned efi file. Latest Ventoy release introduces experimental IMG format support Many thousands of people use Ventoy, the website has a list of tested ISOs. 1. Ventoy should only allow the execution of Secure Boot signed I can provide an option in ventoy.json for user who want to bypass secure boot. What exactly is the problem? 2There are two methods: Enroll Key and Enroll Hash, use whichever one. After installation, simply click the Start Scan button and then press on Repair All. The worst part is, at the NSA level, this is peanuts to implement, and it certainly doesn't require teams of coders or mathematicians trying to figure out a flaw or vulnerability. The injection is just like that I extract the ubuntu.iso and change/add some script and create an new ISO file. Option 2 will be the default option. You signed in with another tab or window. they reviewed all the source code). But, UEFI:NTFS is not a SHIM and that's actually the reason why it could be signed by Microsoft (once I switched the bootloader license from GPLv3+ to GPLv2+ and rewrote a UEFI driver derived from GPLv2+ code, which I am definitely not happy at all about), because, in a Secure Boot enabled environment, it can not be used to chain load anything that isn't itself Secure Boot signed. Okay, I installed linux mint 64 bit on this laptop before. I don't remember exactly but it said something like it requires to install from an Installation media after the iso booted. we have no ability to boot it unless we disable the secure boot because it is not signed. Ventoy - Open source USB boot utility for both BIOS and UEFI Many thanks! preloader-for-ventoy-prerelease-1.0.40.zip, https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/grub2/+bug/1401532, [issue]: Instead of dm-patch, consider a more secure and upstreamable solution that does not do kernel taint. Probably you didn't delete the file completely but to the recycle bin. https://osdn.net/projects/manjaro/storage/kde/, manjaro-kde-20.0-rc3-200422-linux56.iso BOOT Installation & Boot. Thanks! Users may run into issues with Ventoy not working because of corrupt ISO files, which will create problems when booting an image file. Guiding you with how-to advice, news and tips to upgrade your tech life. You can copy several ISO files at a time, and Ventoy will offer a boot menu where you can select them. Ventoy Binary Notes: This website is underprovisioned, so please download ventoy in the follows: (remember to check the SHA-256 hash) https://github.com/ventoy/Ventoy/releases Source Code Ventoy's source code is maintained on both Github and Gitee. Aporteus which is Arch Linux based version of Porteus , is best , fastest and greatest distro i ever met , it's fully modular , supports bleeding edge techs like zstd , have a tool to very easily compile and use latest version of released or RC kernel directly from kernel.org ( Kernel Builder ) , have a tool to generate daily fresh ISO so all the packages are daily and fresh ( Aporteus ISO Builder ) , you can have multi desktops on a ISO and on boot select whatever you like , it has naturally Copy to RAM feature with flag to copy specific modules only so linux run at huge speed , a lot of tools and softwares along side mini size ISO , and it use very very low ram and ISO size, You can generate ISO with whatever language you like to distro have. Create bootable USB drive for ISO/WIM/IMG/VHD(x)/EFI files using Ventoy On Mon, Feb 22, 2021 at 12:25 PM Steve Si ***@***. Any progress towards proper secure boot support without using mokmanager? Thanks a lot. The live folder is similar to Debian live. In Windows, Ventoy2Disk.exe will only list the device removable and in USB interface type by default. downloaded from: http://old-dos.ru/dl.php?id=15030. Error : @FadeMind E2B and grubfm\agFM legacy mode work OK in their default modes. I think it's OK. @adrian15, could you tell us your progress on this? Nevertheless, thanks for the explanation, it cleared up some things for me around the threat model of Secure Boot. ventoy maybe the image does not support x64 uefi By default, secure boot is enabled since version 1.0.76. Can it boot ok? Yes, at this point you have the same exact image as I have. ", same error during creating windows 7 I tested live GeckoLinux STATIC Plasma 152 (based on openSUSE) with ventoy-1.0.15. The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: I believe GRUB (at least v2.04 and previous versions if patched with Fedora patches) already work exactly as you've described. I thought that Secure Boot chain of trust is reused for TPM key sealing, but thinking about it more, that wouldn't really work. I see your point, this CorePlus ISO is indeed missing that EFI file. Vmware) with UEFI mode and to confirm that the ISO file does support UEFI mode. Just like what is the case with Ventoy, I don't have much of an issue with having some leeway, on account that implementing proper signature validation requires some effort, during which unsigned bootloaders may be accepted, so as not inconvenience users too much. Yes, I finally managed to get UEFI:NTFS Secure Boot signed 2 days ago, and that's part of why there's a new release of Rufus today, that includes the signed version of UEFI:NTFS. Of course, there are ways to enable proper validation. Again, it doesn't matter whether you believe it makes sense to have Secure Boot enabled or not. Using Ventoy-1.0.08, ubuntudde-20.04-amd64-desktop.iso is still unable to boot under uefi. Secure Boot is tricky to deal with and can (rightfully) be seen as a major inconvenience instead of yet another usually desireable line of defence against malware (but by all means not a panacea). Hi MFlisar , if you want use that now with HBCD you must extract the iso but the ventoy.dat on the root of the iso recreate the iso with example: ntlite oder oder tools and than you are able to boot from. Now Rufus has achieved support for secure boot as now NTFS:UEFI Driver is signed for secure boot by Microsoft. 3. 5. This could be useful for data recovery, OS re-installation, or just for booting from USB without thinking about additional steps. So use ctrl+w before selecting the ISO. Just create a FAT32 partition, change its label to ARCH_YYYYMM (fill in the ISO's date, now it would be ARCH_202109) and extract the Arch ISO to it. However, after adding firmware packages Ventoy complains Bootfile not found. Even though I copied the Windows 10 ISO to flash drive, which presumably has a UEFI boot image on it, neither of my Vostros would recognize it. I'll think about it and try to add it to ventoy. Can't say for others, but I made Super UEFIinSecureBoot Disk with that exact purpose: to bypass Secure Boot validation policy. I have this same problem. You can't. The main point of Secure Boot is to prevent (or at least warn about) the execution of bootloaders that have not been vetted by Microsoft or one of the third parties that Microsoft signed a shim for (such as Red Hat). First and foremost, disable legacy boot (AKA BIOS emulation). If you burn the image to a CD, and use a USB CD drive, I bet you find it will install fine. check manjaro-gnome, not working. Ventoy has added experimental support for IA32 UEFI since v1.0.30.